
The Supreme Court decides. Section 99 of the Succession Act lets it order that costs be paid out of the estate, or out of assets outside the will, in whatever way it thinks fit. Where a claim settles or succeeds, the claimant’s reasonable costs often come out of the estate, and the executor’s costs usually do too. A claimant who loses can be left paying their own costs, and sometimes the estate’s. The court can cap costs, particularly in estates worth less than $1 million, and in every case it expects costs to stay in proportion to what is being argued over.
Most people who think they have been treated unfairly by a will never find out whether they have a claim. One question stops them before they pick up the phone: what if I lose and end up owing the lawyers more than I was ever going to get?
It is the right question to ask. The honest answer is less simple than “the estate pays”, and more reassuring than many people fear.
What does NSW law say about costs in a will contest?
Contesting a will in NSW usually means making a family provision claim under Chapter 3 of the Succession Act 2006. Costs in those claims are governed by section 99. It lets the court order that the costs of the proceedings, including mediation, be paid out of the estate, the notional estate, or both, in the manner it thinks fit.
That is a wide discretion. In most litigation, the loser pays a large part of the winner’s costs. In Singer v Berghouse (1993), Justice Gaudron of the High Court said family provision cases stand apart from that rule, and that costs generally depend on the overall justice of the case. In practice, the outcome still counts for a lot. The court simply has more room to depart from the usual rule when fairness calls for it.
In practice, the court looks at questions like these:
- Did the claim succeed, settle, or fail?
- Was it reasonable to bring, even if it failed?
- How did each side behave? Were offers made and refused? Was the evidence padded with irrelevant material?
- How big is the estate, and what will a costs order leave for everyone else?
- Can the claimant afford to bear costs?
Who usually pays in each situation?
These are the common patterns. They are tendencies, not promises, because the court decides each case on its facts.
| What happens | Claimant’s own costs | Executor’s costs |
|---|---|---|
| The claim settles at or before mediation | Usually dealt with in the settlement, often paid from the estate | Usually from the estate |
| The claim succeeds at a hearing | Often ordered to be paid from the estate | Usually from the estate |
| The claim fails but was reasonable to bring | Often borne by the claimant, sometimes with no order against them for the estate’s costs | From the estate |
| The claim fails and was weak or run unreasonably | Borne by the claimant, who may also be ordered to pay the estate’s costs | From the estate, sometimes recovered from the claimant |
Most claims never reach the bottom two rows. Under the court’s Practice Note SC Eq 7, the Registrar gives directions early in the case to encourage settlement, and these usually include a referral to mediation. A settlement agreed there will normally say who pays what.
Why does the size of the estate matter so much?
Legal costs come out of the same pool of money everyone is arguing about. Spend too much and there is nothing left worth winning.
The Supreme Court takes this seriously. Its practice note for the Probate and Family Provision List, which started on 17 June 2024, says the court expects estate resources not to be used in a way that is out of proportion to the size of the estate. It also lets the court cap the costs a party can recover. That includes cases where the net distributable estate, before legal costs, is less than $1,000,000.
On the Central Coast, a great many estates are a family home, some savings and some super. Plenty of them fall under that $1 million mark. A cap protects the estate from being eaten by fees, but it also means the costs a claimant can recover from the estate may be limited. Ask your lawyer at the start what happens to any costs above a cap, and whether you would be responsible for them.
Can costs come out of assets that were not in the will?
Yes, and this is one of the features that makes NSW different from other states. Section 99 allows costs to be paid out of the notional estate as well as the estate. Notional estate can include property the person dealt with outside the will, where the court designates it. Examples include:
- some jointly owned assets
- superannuation paid directly to a beneficiary
- recent gifts
So an estate can look tiny on paper because the house was held jointly or the super went straight to one child. That does not automatically make it too small to fund a claim. Have it assessed before you rule a claim out.
Do you have to pay anything upfront?
That depends on the costs agreement you make with your lawyer. Some firms charge as the work is done. Others offer a conditional costs agreement, often called “no win, no fee”. The Law Society Journal explains what the Uniform Law requires of these agreements:
- They must be in writing.
- They must define what counts as a successful outcome.
- They must give you a cooling-off period.
- In litigation, any uplift fee on top of normal costs cannot exceed 25%.
Whichever arrangement you have, the costs will not be hidden. The practice note requires the claimant to file an estimate of their costs up to the end of mediation when the claim is filed. The executor must file one too. Everyone, including the court, can see what is being spent from the start.
How can settlement offers change who pays?
A written offer to settle can shift the costs risk. Say one side makes a reasonable offer, and the other refuses it and then does worse at a hearing. The court can take that refusal into account when deciding costs. It works both ways. A claimant’s sensible offer can put pressure on an executor, and an executor’s sensible offer can expose a claimant who holds out for more.
This is one reason good advice early matters. Knowing the realistic range of outcomes tells you which offers are worth taking.
What about the executor’s side?
An executor who defends a claim is generally entitled to have their reasonable costs paid from the estate, because defending the will is part of their job. That protection is not unlimited. An executor who acts unreasonably, for example by running up costs to protect their own share as a beneficiary, can lose some of it.
If you are the executor rather than the person making the claim, our page on executor and beneficiary representation explains how we help on that side.
So is it worth asking the question?
Almost always, yes. When Ryan & Ryan Lawyers assesses a possible claim, we look at three things:
- whether you are an eligible person
- whether the will made adequate provision for you, given your circumstances
- whether the estate is large enough to justify a claim once costs are counted
If the numbers do not stack up, that is the first thing we will tell you, before any real costs are spent.
Many claims resolve without a hearing. Our case study on a blended-family estate shows one that was settled by negotiation, without the matter going to court.
Timing matters too. A family provision claim generally has to be made within 12 months of the date of death. After that you need the court’s permission, which is harder to get the longer you leave it. If that deadline has already passed, see our page on out-of-time claims and extensions.
Frequently asked questions
Can the executor use estate money to fight my claim?
Generally, yes. An executor’s reasonable costs of defending a family provision claim are usually paid from the estate. That is one reason the court watches proportionality closely: both sides’ costs can end up reducing the estate.
Are the costs rules the same if I think the will itself is invalid?
No. Challenging whether a will is valid, for example because the person lacked capacity or was pressured, is a different kind of case with its own costs principles. Our page on challenging the validity of a will explains the difference.
If I settle, do I still have to pay my lawyer?
Your lawyer’s costs are governed by your costs agreement, whatever the settlement says. Settlements commonly include an amount for costs, or provide for costs to be paid from the estate. Check how your agreement treats any gap before you sign the settlement.
Talk to us before you decide
An early conversation costs far less than finding out the hard way. A copy of the will, if you have one, and a few notes on your circumstances are enough to start. From there we can tell you whether a claim is realistic and what it would cost to run. Call Ryan & Ryan Lawyers on (02) 4397 1500, or get in touch about contesting a will with our team in Toukley or Erina.
If you are an executor wondering what the estate will cost to administer in the first place, our guide to what probate costs in NSW sets out the fees.
This is general information about NSW law current at November 2026, not legal advice for your situation.
